Cheaper: DIY or Buy Closet System? The Ultimate Budget-Friendly Guide
Are you thinking about upgrading your closet but don’t want to break the bank? One big question many homeowners ask is: “Is it cheaper to build a DIY closet system or buy a pre-made one?” The short answer: it depends.
In this guide, we will walk you through a clear, easy-to-understand comparison of DIY vs. buying a closet system. You’ll learn the real costs, pros and cons, hidden expenses, and smart ways to save money either way. By the end, you’ll know which option fits your needs and budget best.
What Is a Closet System?
A closet system is a way to organize your clothes, shoes, and accessories using shelves, drawers, hanging rods, and storage compartments. These systems help keep everything neat and easy to find.
There are two main types:
-
DIY Closet System – You design and build it yourself, using wood, wire shelves, or ready-to-assemble parts.
-
Pre-Made Closet System (Buy) – You purchase a kit or custom-built solution from a store or online.
Each has its own advantages and costs. Let’s break them down.
Part 1: Understanding the Cost of a DIY Closet System
What Is a DIY Closet System?
A DIY closet system is one that you design, purchase materials for, and build on your own. It can be as simple as adding shelves or as complex as building a custom walk-in closet with drawers and lighting.
Pros of a DIY Closet System
✅ Cost Control – You decide how much to spend. Want a cheap setup? Go for basic plywood. Want a more polished look? Add trim and paint.
✅ Customization – Design it exactly how you like. Make space for long dresses, shoes, or accessories.
✅ Satisfaction – There’s a real sense of pride in building something yourself.
✅ Flexibility – You can expand or adjust it over time as your needs change.
Cons of a DIY Closet System
❌ Time-Consuming – It takes time to plan, shop, cut, and install.
❌ Skill Required – You’ll need basic carpentry and measuring skills.
❌ Tools Needed – If you don’t already have tools like a drill, saw, or level, you may need to buy or borrow them.
Real Cost of a DIY Closet System
Let’s look at a basic example. Say you want a reach-in closet (standard size: 6 ft wide). You’ll need:
| Item | Estimated Cost |
|---|---|
| Plywood or MDF Boards | $60 – $100 |
| Closet Rod | $15 – $30 |
| Screws, Nails, Brackets | $10 – $20 |
| Paint or Finish | $15 – $40 |
| Tools (if needed) | $0 – $150 |
| Total Estimated Cost | $100 – $300 |
Note: The cost can go up or down depending on what you already have and how complex the design is.
Part 2: Buying a Closet System
What Is a Pre-Made Closet System?
A pre-made or store-bought closet system comes in a box (or is custom-made), ready to be installed. You can buy them at places like Home Depot, IKEA, Lowe’s, Wayfair, or even Amazon.
Some are adjustable wire systems, others are wood-based modular units. They range from budget kits to luxury walk-ins.
Pros of Buying a Closet System
✅ Easy Installation – Most kits come with instructions and all parts.
✅ Professional Look – The designs are polished and modern.
✅ Time-Saving – No need to plan or cut wood. Just follow the steps.
✅ Customizable Options – Some brands let you pick modules to build a system that works for you.
Cons of Buying a Closet System
❌ More Expensive – Especially for walk-in or custom-built closets.
❌ Limited Flexibility – You’re working with fixed sizes and layouts.
❌ May Not Fit Perfectly – Pre-made units don’t always align with your closet dimensions.
Real Cost of Buying a Closet System
Here’s a breakdown for the same 6 ft wide closet:
| Item | Estimated Cost |
|---|---|
| Basic Wire Shelf Kit | $80 – $120 |
| Mid-Range Modular Wood System | $250 – $600 |
| Custom Closet Design (Installed) | $1000 – $3000+ |
| Installation (if not DIY) | $200 – $500 |
| Total Estimated Cost | $80 – $3500+ |
Hidden Costs to Consider
Whether you go DIY or buy, keep these hidden costs in mind:
-
Delivery Fees – Large kits may require delivery, which adds $50–$100.
-
Waste or Mistakes – Errors in measuring or cutting can cost more in materials.
-
Time Value – Time spent planning, shopping, and installing has a cost too.
-
Modifications – Some closets need patching, painting, or repairs before installing a new system.
Which Is Cheaper: DIY or Buy?
Short Answer: DIY closet systems are usually cheaper upfront—especially for small, simple closets.
Long Answer: The cheapest option depends on your:
-
Skill level
-
Tools already owned
-
Time availability
-
Closet size and shape
-
Design preference
If you already have tools and basic skills, DIY is definitely the cheaper choice.
However, if you want a polished finish, quick setup, and less hassle, a store-bought kit might be worth the extra money.
Comparison Table: DIY vs. Buy Closet System
| Feature | DIY Closet System | Store-Bought Closet System |
|---|---|---|
| Cost | $100 – $300+ | $150 – $3500+ |
| Skill Required | Medium to High | Low to Medium |
| Time to Build | 1 – 2 days | Few hours – 1 day |
| Tools Needed | Yes | Usually minimal |
| Custom Fit | Fully customizable | Limited sizes |
| Look & Finish | Varies | Consistent and clean |
| Satisfaction Level | High (if successful) | Medium to High |
Best Budget-Friendly Closet Options
Here are some smart ideas if you want to save money but still have a functional and stylish closet:
1. IKEA Hack Closet Systems
Combine IKEA pieces like BILLY bookcases, KALLAX cubes, and KOMPLEMENT drawers to create a custom closet.
2. Use a Combination
Start with a cheap shelf kit and add DIY upgrades like trim, baskets, or lighting.
3. Dollar Store Closet Organization
Buy bins, hangers, and organizers from budget stores to tidy up a basic closet.
4. Second-Hand Finds
Check Facebook Marketplace, Craigslist, or local thrift stores for used closet systems at low prices.
Tips to Save Money on Closet Projects
-
Measure carefully to avoid costly mistakes.
-
Sketch a plan before you shop.
-
Shop sales at home improvement stores.
-
Use leftover materials from other projects.
-
Ask friends or neighbors to borrow tools.
-
Watch YouTube tutorials for free guidance.
Final Thoughts: DIY or Buy?
Still wondering which to choose? Here’s a quick decision guide:
-
✅ Choose DIY if:
-
You enjoy hands-on projects
-
You want to save the most money
-
You’re customizing an odd-sized closet
-
You already have tools and time
-
-
✅ Choose Buy if:
-
You want quick results
-
You’re not confident in building
-
You like a modern, clean finish
-
You’re okay spending more for convenience
-
Verdict: For small or simple closets, DIY is usually cheaper. But for large or elegant walk-ins, buying a ready-made or custom system might be worth the cost.